★ 2

Becca is an incredible coach! She’s welcoming, supportive, and always takes the time to answer any questions. Her knowledge and dedication have helped create such an inclusive and motivating environment. This is, without a doubt, the best gym I’ve ever been part of.
The workouts are challenging yet flexible, with modifications available for every fitness level. Since joining, I’ve become stronger and more confident in what my body can do—tasks that once felt too hard are now completely doable!
The community here is amazing—everyone is friendly and encouraging, and the social events make it feel even more like a family. I can’t say enough great things about this gym. If you’re looking to push yourself, grow stronger, and connect with awesome people, I highly recommend it!

Source: Google

★ 5

Ian is very attentive, he takes time with each athlete to give specific feedback. He models movement and truly has an innate ability to adjust to everyone’s learning style. I feel welcome and a sense of belonging in his classes . Thank you Ian!

Source: Google

★ 5

The best part about this gym, other than getting super strong, is that now random passerbys at other gyms compliment my lift form! These are skills I'll have for life, super pumped about it.

Source: Google

★ 5

Sam, the physical therapist /coach, Is amazing, very helpful with each part of working out in the gym, sometimes I forget the met con, He is very helpful and getting me back on track, With a smile on his face, 😊

Source: Google

★ 5

Matt was an excellent coach. With it being my first class, he explained and even modified the exercises for me. He was positive, encouraging, and motivating. I was sweating and definitely got a work out.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

The workout with coach Matt was great! He definitely creates a positive and fun atmosphere!

Source: Google

★ 5

Great first class for me. Becca was very supportive and ensures that I was not pushing myself too hard after returning from my injury. Highly recommend her and the cardio class!

Source: Google

★ 5

Becca was super encouraging. I had shared with her that I hadn’t worked out in a couple weeks and she told me to take it slow and trust my body will get back to where it was pre-break. As soon as I walked in it was like Becca had known me for years! She is super personable and wants to help everyone live a happier, healthier life- even if she needs to modify every exercise for you. She is extremely knowledgeable and will drop random anatomy questions into class. I highly recommend!!

Source: Google

★ 5

Had my first class today and Becca was nothing but helpful, encouraging, and supporting. I will definitely be coming back for more classes with her!!

Source: Google

★ 5

Amazing first visit at the gym. everyone was super supportive and kind. got a great workout in!

Source: Google

★ 5

Had my first class today and Samuel was amazing. He screened for my past experiences and current activity level and made my experience great. He was also very supportive and attentive with my movements and executions throughout the class. I loved it!

Source: Google

★ 5

Coach Zach gave clear, timely feedback on a lift I’d been stuck on, and explained the ‘why’ behind the technique in a way that really clicked. It’s something I’ll remember every time I do it. Definitely recommend 🌟

Source: Google

★ 5

The coaches and vibe here are always amazing! As a more “antisocial” introvert, gyms have been a little intimidating for me, but everyone here makes sure you feel comfortable and confident everyday! Becca is an amazing coach always pumping you up and celebrating all your accomplishments no matter how small. And Matt is awesome! Always provides good feedback and I never feel lost in the workouts! If you’ve been on the fence about joining just do it! You won’t regret it!

Source: Google

★ 5

Becca is an amazing coach! She is very welcoming and always takes time to make sure she answers any questions. She is knowledgeable and has created an inclusive environment. This is hands down the best gym I have been a part of.

The workouts are challenging but can always be modified to your level of fitness. Being part of this gym has made me stronger and more confident in my abilities. My new strength has helped me with my everyday life. Things that were once too heavy/difficult are now achievable!

The gym has a great group of people who are very welcoming. There are also social events which adds to the community feeling. I truly can’t say enough about how awesome and unique this gym is. Highly recommend to anyone looking to challenge themselves and meet some great people!

Source: Google

★ 5

I had a great first workout at Nickel City! Everyone was super supportive and encouraging and Becca modified the class to meet my needs and cheered me on every step of the way. Exceeded my expectations and I’m looking forward to going back asap!

Source: Google

★ 5

I can't rave enough about Becca/NCA! This community is one of the most inviting and inclusive i've seen in Buffalo. The coaching model is the closet i've had to personal training and is incredibly motivating.

Source: Google

★ 5

Becca explains each workout throughly, Keeps a watchful eye on us to make sure our form is correct, and the music was GOLD

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

It's definitely a great place for any fitness journey. It's friendly oriented, the coaches are very informative, and will take the time to work with you. I would recommend this place to anyone!

Source: Google

★ 5

If you want a no clique, welcoming, low stress yet still challenging functional fitness gym, this is the one for you! Not to mention fun community events.

Source: Google

★ 5

I absolutely love this gym! The coaches and the members of this gym do a great job of making everyone feel welcome and included, regardless of what fitness level you are at. The classes are all programmed with lots of modifications for weights and movements so that everyone is able to get the best workout they can for *themselves*. I have never been someone that particularly likes going to the gym. But since coming here, I now look forward to working out. Also, as long as you show up and put in the work, you will improve so much, which is very fun and rewarding!

Source: Google

★ 5

This place is AMAZING! It's a great gym and atmosphere for anyone and all skill levels, especially beginners! I was very new to functional fitness and weightlifting when I joined, but everyone here is welcoming and inclusive. All of the coaches are very knowledgeable! I've been going here for two and a half years now and I have this gym to thank for my strength (I'm in the best shape of my life, so far).

The coaches are very good about creating modifications for each part of the workouts. When I first began at NCA, I had some chronic hip pain. While going to PT (in house), I had to modify workouts for a really long time.. While it was discouraging at the time, the coaches were great and motivated me to modify the workouts to different workout that were still challenging but didn't bother me. Once my hip pain went away, I was still conditioned to the programming from modifying and continuing the workouts in a safe way. I have the coaches and PT to thank for this!

My favorite part about this gym is the community and the app. The app is great for tracking goals and PR's. For anyone considering joining a gym, I highly recommend NCA!

Source: Google

★ 5

Nickel City is an amazing community of coaches and athletes - and has been a space where I’ve been able to grow over the years. They support each person’s goals and celebrate all fitness levels. I whole heartedly recommend this gym to folks interested or wanting to find a fitness home.

**Updating in late 2024: I’ve been a member of this gym since Becca became the owner in 2021. This is a fabulous gym, and is even more so a fantastic community. NCA is the gym where I get strong, and found someone willing to check in on my new kitten when I was away all day for work. It’s where I hit some heavy lifts and found support to move heavy furniture when I moved. It’s where I get pretty sweaty, and am lent a drill so I can put something together at home. This is a wonderful place to be that I strongly recommend to anyone considering joining a gym in WNY.

Source: Google

★ 5

This women-owned business caught my attention after having three children and trying to find my way back to fitness. After three kids and some lifelong back issues, Becca helped me realize I could get back in the fitness game with the new body I'd been given after three kids. What a great community to step back into.

Source: Google

★ 5

Nickel City Athletics is a great space with adaptable programming for all fitness levels and passionate coaches who inspire us to do our best in class. There is a place for everyone here!

Source: Google

★ 5

I have been a member of Nickel City for over two years now, and always look forward to starting my day with this community. The programming is top notch, allowing you to clearly see your progress and reach your goals. The facility is clean with updated amenities and equipment. Most importantly, the member community is like no other. If you are looking for a group to motivate and encourage you, look no further!!!

Source: Google

★ 5

Very welcoming with friendly members and staff. Great community feel, everything is clean and updated.

Source: Google

★ 5

Went to the 6:30AM class.
Good vibe, good music.
Great programming

Source: Google

★ 5

Comfortable place to work out without any distractions. Clean, knowledgeable staff.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Love this gym & community ☺️

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

NCA truly deserves all the five-star reviews you're seeing here and then some. Not only is this a gym that is staffed with top-notch, caring, and knowledgable coaches who push you to be the best you can be, it is also a community. Becca has created a place where everyone is welcome, no matter who they are, and that welcoming spirit is what has allowed me to push myself and achieve more than I ever thought possible, and make some amazing friends along the way.

Source: Google

★ 5

NCA is the best gym out there for it's community/people, programming, motivation, and coaching. tl;dr

At NCA the workout programming and environment are great for all levels of experience and skill. As a former athlete with many lingering injuries, fitness was becoming a constant barrage of battling injuries and lack of motivation. At NCA I've found new motivation and levels to my fitness; thanks to great coaches leading proper (targeted) warm-ups, re-visiting/re-learning proper lifting form, friendly competition, and an incredible community of people. The members are always encouraging and the coaches are fantastic. It doesn't matter what you're looking for in your fitness journey, you'll find support for it here (and even if you don't know what you're looking for, chances are you'll find that here too)

Source: Google

★ 5

2023 Update: No lies detected from my earlier post. Still the funnest gym with the funnest community. What are you waiting for?

If you’re looking for a new gym to make your home in 2023, this is the place. I’ve been coming to this location for over 7 years and it’s hands down the best gym community. Great programming and you get a good workout every time. Everyone is so friendly & supportive, and there’s a ton of fun events that are thrown. You won’t regret it!

Source: Google

★ 5

Nickel City Athletics truly is the best gym in Buffalo! All of the coaches are so helpful and knowledgeable, and the entire community is always so welcoming and makes you feel like you belong no matter where you are in your fitness journey. You come for the fitness but stay for the awesome people you meet along the way!

Source: Google

★ 5

I've been a member for over seven years and going to class is still what I look forward to most on any given day. I am still being challenged and still achieving new milestones. There's no better place in Buffalo to find out what you're truly capable of. 👌🏼

Source: Google

★ 5

I relocated to Buffalo for work and was looking for group fitness class that would give me more personal experience. I found Nickel City through google and decided to join it. I liked all the gym staff, they made me feel welcome. Loved classes of Julia and Lara, they were very patient with the beginner like me. Definitely recommend if you are looking for more personal experience and fun fitness classes at a reasonable price.

Source: Google

★ 5

NCA is seriously a 10/10 establishment. The community here is second to none. Wether you are just starting your fitness journey, have been working out forever, or have taken a break and want to get back into it, this is the place for you. The coaches here are so supportive and welcoming and give you the one on one attention you need in group classes to make you feel safe and comfortable with all the movements. I have found such an incredible community here and am so grateful for all the friends I have made! I’ve never experienced such a kind and supportive atmosphere in fitness before and will never need to look anywhere else.

Source: Google

★ 5

I would give more stars if I could!

I had been wanting to join a gym for a while, and wanted to support a local place--I was looking around for places online and stumbled on Nickel City Athletics. I honestly could not be happier that I found it. Amazing owner, amazing coaches, amazing people all around! I was SUPER nervous to start because I hadn't set foot in a gym in at least 6 or 7 years, but skill or experience level didn't matter whatsoever. The owner, Becca, helped me from day 1 to find workouts that catered to my physical ability while still pushing me, and the group workouts have helped me stay accountable while genuinely having fun working out with people from every different level. Everyone is incredibly supportive of each other, which makes the whole experience so much better, and actually makes it fun to do all of these workouts. NCA even has an app where you can reserve spots for classes, interact with each other, and to log your results to see how much you've improved since you've started. The gym has everything you would need for the workouts and classes that they focus on, and is just an all-around wonderful environment. Like I said--I really couldn't speak higher of Nickel City Athletics, and am lucky to be a part of such an incredible community!

Source: Google

★ 5

TL;DR: This is the gym you’ve been looking for! Coaching and programming are top notch and you will be walking into a community of people who are always happy to see you, cheer you on, and celebrate you every step of the way. I am so glad I found NCA! Huge love to Becca and the coaching staff who make this place a joy to walk into (and hobble out of 😉) everyday!

The novel: Nickel City Athletics is a special place. I walked in the door a year ago when a family member who was visiting from out of town told me NCA was their favorite gym to workout at whenever they’re back in Buffalo. I was skeptical about functional fitness but the skilled coaching staff, fresh programming and incredibly welcoming and inclusive community won me over. As someone who has been athletic most of my life, I feel like I am growing stronger and gaining endurance for the first time in a long time (I also know this because there’s a whole tracking system you can use to monitor your progress if you’re into that sort of thing!) I hugely appreciate that if I ever need to modify an exercise or scale a workout, the knowledgeable coaching staff helps me adapt on the spot. This is a place where health, safety, and the long-term healthy movement of your body is prioritized over being gym class heroes (although there’s a yearly field day event for bringing out your inner child!) And this is a place where every background and skill level is not only welcomed, but celebrated.

In addition to the coaching and programming there’s always a slew of fun activities to be partake in as you’d like (see aforementioned field day). And you can also skip that if it’s not your jam! Other bonuses: showers on-site, swag that you will want to wear (and may find hard to stop buying?), seminars to learn more about certain skills and topics related to functional fitness & snacks and hydration for sale on site when you need it!

Beyond the specifics outlined here, this place has a magic that’s hard to pin down. I think it’s being in a space where everyone around you wants you to succeed - it rubs off on you and you can’t help but celebrate the milestones that others achieve and know this community is behind you as you make strides in the direction you want to move in. Come on by and see for yourself!

Source: Google

★ 5

I tried out Nickel City Athletics because I was struggling to stay motivated at a large chain gym. Now, I look forward to going (almost) every day. Thanks to the awesome coaches and top-notch workout programming, I’m stronger and fitter; but even better, I’m happier and having more fun! I love the camaraderie at NCA: Becca and the staff have truly created a positive, inclusive, and encouraging fitness community.

Source: Google

★ 5

As someone relatively new to fitness, I notice a difference in my strength, technique, and overall confidence in the gym since I’ve started coming. Everyone is always welcoming and encouraging.

Source: Google

★ 5

Since joining about a year ago it has been a great experience. Everyday is about learning somthing new. From the coaching staff to the members, it is a very welcoming community, no matter your level of fitness. Working through Inexperience, limitations or injury they will know how to scale a workout appropriately.

I highly recommend trying out a class or two and see for yourself!

Source: Google

★ 5

Best gym ever! I was nervous to try their classes, having only ever lifted on my own (& never tried Olympic lifts), but Becca & her coaches are amazing. They offer modifications for every movement & if you have any injuries they’re helpful with figuring out what movement is best for you. Nickel City is such an amazing mix of people who are incredibly in shape & people who are new to lifting, and everyone is challenged by the workouts.

Source: Google

★ 5

Have been going to Nickel City for close to a year now - it is full of wonderful people from ownership to coaches to members. The classes, programming and community helped me surpass my original expectations for fitness goals through the knowledgable/attentive coaching staff, and challenging workouts - while keeping everything fun and loose at the same time. I look forward to going to class no matter how difficult the workout might look, and will continue to invite friends along to share the experience and atmosphere

Source: Google

★ 5

Best gym in Buffalo! The owner and other coaches are very adept to functional movements and the body mechanics of exercise. If you’re looking for a fun community with tough work outs tailored to your own body, this is the place!!!! 10/10 recommend 🔥

Source: Google

★ 5

Nickel City Athletics is such an amazing place. Since I walked in on a recommendation and took my first class, I was hooked! The coaches and owner made me feel so comfortable and safe learning new movements as a beginner in crossfit movements. I can’t recommend checking it out enough!

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Wish I could give it 6 stars

Source: Google

★ 5

The owner and staff are all extremely welcoming and work with each person to help them achieve whatever fitness goals they may have. The atmosphere and the great people push you to do more. I would recommend them to anyone no matter where you are on your fitness journey!

Source: Google

★ 5

Love this gym. Very welcoming and accommodating. Always leave feeling challenged but accomplished.

Source: Google

★ 5

This gym is incredible! The coaches are extremely knowledgeable and the focus is about achieving the intended stimulus and making genuine improvement, NOT lifting too much, too fast. I’ve destroyed my knees through prior sports and activities, and in the last couple of months, my knees feel healthier and stronger than they ever did after months of physical therapy. I appreciate that everyday the coaches scale the workout to each individual’s needs, ensuring for safe, gradual improvement that you’re sure to see, as long as you keep coming back. 12/10 Highly recommend; no matter where you’re starting from or what your background is. P.S. Our dog also loves open gym! (As a member you’ll have 24/7 access to the gym)

Source: Google

★ 5

I come for the spicy programming and stay for the friendly staff and members. NCA makes me excited to go to the gym and encourages me to work toward reaching my fitness goals and maintain healthy habits. No toxic vibes at this place, just good people all working toward bettering themselves every day.

Source: Google

★ 5

I've never felt a stronger or more welcoming sense of community within a gym. Great programming with a genuine focus on finding the right levels for everyone.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Great coaches here, they take the time to show proper technique and warm up at the beginning of every class. Definitely recommend for those looking for a fun, high paced workout!

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

I’ve known and worked with the owner, Becca, for years. She has an excellent approach to fitness and it comes through as professional and caring. She provides an environment that is judgement free and accepting to everyone. I started my fitness journey later in life, and she helped me by being thoughtful about scaling movements to my ability, but she also pushed me enough so that I was able to progress. She started as my personal running coach a few years ago and I went from being a non-runner to completing a half marathon and continually being able to shave time off my 5k’s. It does not matter what level of fitness you are at, Becca WILL be able to help with your fitness goals!

Source: Google

★ 5

Nickel City Athletics was a very welcoming experience. The trainer as well as the owner were extremely knowledgeable about the programming, and explained things for a newcomer. Everyone was also encouraging during the partner workout, which helped me complete the workout. I recommend this gym for anyone new or old to fitness. It is worth the investment and your time. Will be back 100%.

Source: Google

★ 5

Excellent facility with all the equipment you need to stay or get fit. Knowledgeable owner and coaches along with a clean facility. Would highly recommend

Source: Google

★ 5

Are you looking to get shredded? Are you looking to get real succulent? Are you tryna get lean and mean? Are you trying to find an escape from the endless soul crushing grind of life being exploited by our capitalist oppressors? Are you just trying to take care of your health, mental and physical? Do you want to feel supported and experience a camaraderie built from shared experiences and mutual respect?

Well good news! You’ll find all of that here! Friendly and knowledgeable coaches, and the other members have been very friendly to me as a relative newcomer.

They also carry my favorite flavor Bang energy drink.

Source: Google

★ 5

Nickel City Athletics is such an awesome community! No matter what your fitness level, background etc., they are very welcoming, caring and attentive to movement quality and modifying the workout to everyone's personal needs, truly great coaching! I always feel better after leaving class!

Source: Google

★ 5

I've been going to crossfit/functional fitness gyms for the past 6 years up and down the east coast. This gym is hands down the best I have had the pleasure of being a member at.

The coaches are knowledgeable, and actually care about the ability of the athletes at the gym. Prior injuries or a tweaked back from sleeping the wrong way? The coaches will adjust the movements to make sure you can get a good workout safely.

The atmosphere at the gym is also great. This isn't an intimidating environment at all. Everybody that walks through the front door is greeted by the whole gym and is made to feel like they've been there for years. No matter what kind of weight you are moving, everybody is excited when another member in the class PRs.

Overall this is a great gym if you are looking to get fit, have fun, and make friends while doing it!

Source: Google

★ 5

Love my experience at NCA! As a new comer I’ve felt so welcomed by everyone and love the smaller gym atmosphere. It has changed the way I look at working out and I look forward to each class!

Source: Google

★ 5

Great gym! Super knowledgeable coaches scaled my workout to my ability but still pushed me past my comfort zone. 24/7 access a real plus.

Source: Google

★ 5

Amazing facilities and coaches!

Source: Google

★ 5

Such a friendly community! The new owner really goes out of her way to make you feel welcome and comfortable. It can be intimidating to start going to a new gym - but that feeling goes away almost immediately at Nickel City Athletics, and I definitely appreciate that!

Source: Google

★ 5

I love working out at Nickel City Athletics. Fun people, no attitudes and everyone is supportive. Great place!

Source: Google

★ 5

Amazing location. The instructors are supportive and very knowledgeable

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Nickel City is great! The instructors offer excellent programming with a fantastic emphasis on moving better and getting stronger. It is a positive, supportive attitude that focuses on strengthening your body rather than being at war with it. The ethos extends all the way down to the other members and there are no jerks.

Even in a class setting, they find ways to focus on individual athletes and customize the class to each athlete's abilities, needs, and goals.

Moreover, in these times of COVID 19 they are doing an excellent job with social distancing and adding additional outdoor programming.

I have done time as a professional athlete and it was very important to me to find skilled, responsible coaches who would get beneficial results, without being reckless, overdoing it, or risking injury that would keep me from my main sport. In fact, when I got injured in my main sport, I continued coming to Nickel City during recovery and they helped me keep a fitness baseline, rehab, and get full functionality back.

I highly recommend Nickel City for everyone - from people who just want to get stronger and healthier in daily life, to pro athletes looking for a holistic, all around program to benefit and increase performance in their main sport.

The coaching, training, and programming at this gym are top class!

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Instructors here are AMAZING

Source: Google

★ 4

Source: Google

★ 5

Losing that weight

Source: Google

★ 5

I dropped into this box on Sat June 15 2019 with my wife for a Saturday Wod. I travel for work and drop-in regularly worldwide, this was my first here. Kyle was the coach.

I was impressed at how organized the box was. Everyone had to sign up and pay (20$) in advance online for the drop in. All payment and waivers signed through wodify. Gym is small-med size but had great rogue equipment (like sandbags) that are not commonly found in boxes.

Coach Kyle was great at remembering our names in a class of 10plus and divided attention evenly during the sat partner wod. we had people from Rx to intro people. He came over to every single person to ensure we could scale accordingly before the start. There was a small game to wamrup everyone as well.

If I ever moved to Buffalo this would be my new home box.

Drop in here. T shirts 10$ extra.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Your fitness goals start here

Source: Google

★ 5

Great owners

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 1

Source: Google

★ 5

Excellent coaching, fun programming, great atmosphere

Source: Google

★ 5

Love this place! Everyone is very encouraging and the instructors are top-notch.

Source: Google

★ 5

Coaches who know movement well and push you to excel without getting injured. A great environment full of encouragement and jokes! Perfect for those brand new to cross fit or seasoned athletes!

Source: Google

★ 4

Gym with everything you need. Great trainers that will push you through barriers

Source: Google

★ 5

I love working out here - it's a great community and the combination of a physical therapist and a crossfit gym is really great for form and body movement

Source: Google

★ 5

I own 3 boxes in NYC, I've been woding for 6 years, twice a year I come up to Bflo and this box is one of the best in Western NY. Rachel, our coach when I dropped in was on point, knowledgable and kept the class moving, the athletes were a cheerful group and the box is well appointed. Keep it up CF Nickel City!!!!!!

Source: Google

★ 3

I dropped into this box. Maybe I'm spoiled by the gym I go to at home but this place just didn't cut it for me. Don't get me wrong the people are very nice but 1) they don't show you how movements are done before the workouts start 2) Their rig only has enough room for 3 people to work at a time, with a class with 15+ people you just can't get anything done 3)For the 15+ people that were in the class there was only 1 coach! How can you make sure every is doing movements properly with only 1 coach! Thats not safe. This gym could be great, it just needs some work.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Best Crossfit gym in Buffalo

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google